Sunday, November 22, 2026
RankPublish

Guest posting, link building & SEO magazine

Competitor Backlink Analysis: How to Find the Links Worth Copying

Competitor backlink analysis shows you which sites link to your rivals but not to you. This step by step guide covers the full link gap workflow, how to judge which links are worth earning, and the honest limits of copying a rival profile.

By Shamon· · 15 min read
Competitor backlink analysis comparing three website link profiles with a magnifying glass over the link gap.

Two thirds of the pages on the web have no backlinks at all. Ahrefs worked through more than a billion pages in its index and found that 66.31 percent of them did not have a single referring domain pointing at them. Your competitors are probably not in that silent majority. If a rival sits above you in the search results month after month, there is a good chance their link profile is part of the reason, and competitor backlink analysis is how you find out which part.

This guide walks through the whole workflow in order: choosing the right rivals, exporting their links, finding the gap between their profile and yours, judging which links are genuinely worth chasing, and doing the outreach that turns a spreadsheet into results. It also covers the part most guides leave out. Some of what you find in a rival profile is paid, some of it is toxic, and copying a link profile is not the same thing as copying the rankings that came with it.

What competitor backlink analysis actually is

Competitor backlink analysis is the process of studying the links pointing to rival websites so you can find linking sites that might link to you as well. That is the simple version. The useful version is narrower. You are not collecting every link a competitor has. You are looking for patterns: the kinds of sites that link to them, the content those links point to, and the linking domains that show up for two or three rivals but not for you. A domain that links to three of your competitors is telling you something about your niche. It covers your topic, it links out to sites like yours, and it has already decided that sites like yours are worth referencing.

Done well, competitor backlink analysis replaces guesswork with a shortlist. Instead of pitching hundreds of random blogs, you work from a list of sites that have demonstrated, in public, that they link to businesses in your space. That is a far warmer starting point than a cold list scraped from a directory.

It helps to be clear about what the analysis cannot do. It shows you the links a tool has found, which is most links but never all of them. It shows you where links point, not why an editor added them, and not what the competitor paid, traded, or did three years ago to earn them. Treat the output as intelligence, not as a shopping list.

What the numbers say about the link gap

The Ahrefs figures are worth sitting with for a moment, because they explain why this work matters. In that same study of more than a billion pages, around 90 percent of pages received no organic traffic from Google at all, and a lack of backlinks was one of the clearest patterns among the invisible pages. Links are not the whole of search ranking, and nobody serious claims they are. But a page with no links is asking Google to trust it on its own say so, and Google rarely does.

The practical reading is this. When your page and a rival page cover a topic equally well, the one with stronger and more relevant links usually wins. So the question competitor backlink analysis answers is not whether links matter. It is which specific links explain the difference between your profile and the profiles ranking above you, and how many of those links are realistically within your reach.

There is a second, quieter lesson in the data. Because most pages have no links, you do not need to match a big competitor link for link. You need enough good links, from relevant sites, to stop being invisible in your corner of the niche. For most small sites the gap that matters is measured in dozens of decent referring domains, not thousands.

Step 1: Pick competitors worth analysing

Start with the rivals Google already rewards, not the brands you happen to admire. Search for the five or six queries that bring in your customers and note which sites appear on page one again and again. Those are your search competitors, and they are not always your business competitors. A local plumber competes for links with national advice sites and directories as much as with the firm across town.

Pick three to five of them. Fewer than three and the patterns are hard to spot. More than five and the exports become noise you will never work through. A good set usually mixes one or two direct rivals of a similar size to you, because their links are the most attainable, with one larger player whose profile shows you where the ceiling sits.

Ignore, for now, the giants whose link profiles rest on being famous. A national newspaper or a household brand earns links by existing, and their profile will teach you almost nothing you can act on. If one dominates your results pages, include them in the export for context, but do not build your plan around their links.

You also need your own profile in the same spreadsheet. If you have never looked at it properly, run your own domain through a tool that checks backlinks for free first so you know your starting point: how many referring domains you have, which pages attract them, and which of your links are already the kind you want more of.

Step 2: Export their backlink profiles

Every serious SEO tool, Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz, and several cheaper options, will export a competitor backlink profile as a spreadsheet. You want one row per linking page, with the referring domain, the target page on the competitor site, the anchor text, and some measure of the linking site quality. Most tools charge a monthly subscription, and a typical professional plan runs from around 100 to 200 dollars a month. If budget is tight, one month is enough to do this whole exercise properly. Export everything, cancel, and work from the files. That single month of data is the raw material of competitor backlink analysis, and it is cheaper than a year of guessing where your rivals links came from.

Export each competitor separately rather than merging them at this stage. You need to know which links belong to whom, because the overlap between rivals is the most valuable signal you have, and you lose it the moment the data is blended.

While the exports are running, note the pages on each competitor site that attract the most links. This matters more than the raw totals. If one rival guide has earned links from 60 domains while the rest of their site has almost none, that guide is the real asset. Your analysis should end up being about content and relationships, and the most linked pages show you both.

Link gap diagram showing domains that link to competitors but not to your site.

Step 3: Find the link gap

The link gap is the set of domains that link to your competitors but not to you. Most tools have a dedicated link gap or backlink gap view: you enter your domain and your rivals, and it returns the domains that link to them and not to you, usually with a filter for domains linking to several rivals at once. That filter is where you start.

Work down the list in that order and sort what you find into rough groups:

  1. Sites that link to several rivals. These cover your niche and link out freely. Highest priority.

  2. Resource pages, directories, and curated lists in your industry. Often a simple submission or a short pitch.

  3. Blogs and publications that ran a story, interview, or roundup featuring a rival. A pitch angle usually exists.

  4. Sites linking to one rival only. Worth a look, but check the reason for the link before spending time.

  5. Everything else, including the odd, the irrelevant, and the clearly bought. Most of this gets deleted in the next step.

This sorting is the heart of competitor backlink analysis, and it is judgment work, not data entry. Two analysts can export the same profiles and produce very different shortlists. The difference is how honestly they sort.

If this is your first time working through a gap list, the broader methods in our guide to how to get backlinks will help you match each group to a realistic way of earning that kind of link, from digital PR to simple resource page requests.

Step 4: Judge which links are worth copying

A domain on your gap list has to pass four quick tests before it earns a place on your outreach list. First, relevance. Does the site cover your topic or your customers world? A link from a site in your industry is worth far more than a stronger link from somewhere unrelated. Second, reality. Does the site look alive, with recent posts, real readers, and an actual audience? Third, traffic. A linking site that gets no visitors itself is usually a site nobody reads, and its links carry little weight. Fourth, the reason for the original link. Open the page that links to your competitor and read it. If the link sits naturally inside useful content, good. If it sits in a footer, a blogroll, or a page of thin text stuffed with unrelated links, you are looking at a paid placement or a link scheme, and you should walk away. This judging step is where competitor backlink analysis earns its money back, because every bad link you cross off the list is a fee, a favour, or a penalty you never have to pay.

That last test is where beginners lose money. Competitor profiles in competitive niches are full of links the competitor bought. Copying those links means buying them too, and bought links sit squarely inside the link spam rules in Google spam policies , which describe exactly this kind of manipulation. A rival may get away with it for a year. That does not make it a strategy.

Keep a simple score for each candidate: relevance, site quality, and how plausible your pitch is. Anything weak on relevance is out, whatever its authority score says. If you want a grounding in what separates a strong link from a hollow metric, our explainer on high authority backlinks covers the difference between a domain rating and a link that actually moves a page.

Step 5: Earn the links with outreach

Now the analysis turns into work. For each surviving domain, find the specific reason they would link to you, and write it down in one sentence before you contact anyone. The strongest reasons mirror what already worked for your competitor. If they linked to a rival guide because it answered a question well, your pitch is a better or fresher guide. If they listed a rival in a roundup of tools or suppliers, your pitch is a request to be considered for the list, with a clear reason your site belongs there. If they interviewed a rival founder, your pitch is a different voice on the same topic.

Keep the emails short, personal, and honest. Mention the page you are talking about, show that you have read it, and make the suggestion easy to say yes to. Send in small batches, twenty to thirty careful pitches at a time, and track replies in the same spreadsheet. Expect reply rates to be modest. In most niches, a well targeted campaign turns somewhere between one in ten and one in twenty pitches into a conversation, and fewer still into a live link. That is normal, and it is why the quality of the shortlist matters more than the size of it.

Where a gap domain linked to a competitor page that no longer exists, or to content that has gone stale, you have an even easier conversation: you can offer your working page as the replacement. Broken link opportunities like this sit inside most gap lists, hiding in plain sight. Keep the spreadsheet from your competitor backlink analysis open while you work the list, because the reason each site linked to a rival is written in it, and your pitch should answer that reason.

For the wider playbook on turning link targets into a campaign, the methods in our proven link building approaches guide pair well with a gap list, because the gap list tells you where to aim and the strategies tell you how to approach each kind of site.

Small online store comparing its backlink profile with two larger competitors.

A worked example: the small store and the two big rivals

Consider a realistic scenario. A family run kitchenware store sells online and has 48 referring domains after three years of trading. Two national retailers dominate its search results. A month of a professional tool subscription, around 130 dollars, produces exports showing the first retailer with roughly 310 referring domains and the second with about 190. The raw gap list is discouraging: more than 400 domains link to one rival or the other. Filtering changes the picture. Domains linking to both rivals come to 63. Removing dead sites, unrelated sites, and obvious paid placements leaves 41. Of those, 18 are food blogs and recipe sites that link to retailer product guides, 9 are local and national press, 8 are curated lists of independent kitchen shops, and 6 are suppliers and makers whose stockists pages list retailers. The store cannot chase the national press links yet, and it knows it. It starts with the two groups built for businesses like it: the stockist pages, which need a simple request and proof of a real trading relationship, and the independent shop lists, which need a short pitch and a good story. It also commissions one proper buying guide, the kind of page the food blogs kept linking to, rather than another thin blog post. Over the following three months it sends about 40 pitches in total and earns 11 new links. Not 400. Eleven. But they are relevant, they sit on sites that link to both big rivals, and within two more months three of the store category pages have moved from page three to page one for smaller, buying intent searches. That is what a good outcome actually looks like at this scale.

The honest limits of competitor backlink analysis

Here is the part to read twice. Copying a link profile is not copying rankings. Rankings rest on the competitor content, their brand searches, their internal linking, their history, and a hundred small things your spreadsheet cannot see. Two sites can hold near identical links and rank very differently because one answers the query better. Competitor backlink analysis gives you a map of one factor, a real one, but only one.

Second, some of what you find will be rotten. In most commercial niches, a slice of every rival profile is paid links, expired domain tricks, or old directory spam that the competitor may not even know about. Chasing those links copies the risk without copying whatever else keeps the rival afloat. If a manual action or an algorithmic filter ever lands, profiles built on bought links fall hardest. The background reading in the Ahrefs link building guide and the Moz guide to backlinks both make the same point from different directions: the links worth having are the ones an editor would defend.

Third, the work costs time and money. A tool subscription, several days of sorting and judging, and weeks of outreach for a return measured in single figures of links per month. For a very small site, fixing weak content and earning a few links through suppliers, local press, and good guides may beat a full analysis. Competitor backlink analysis earns its keep when you already have decent content that is losing to similar content with better links. That is the situation it was built for.

Finally, the data is a snapshot. Tools miss links, competitors gain new ones weekly, and a gap list ages fast. Revisit the analysis once or twice a year rather than treating it as a permanent map.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I run a competitor backlink analysis?

Once or twice a year is enough for most small and mid sized sites. Run it again sooner if a new rival pushes into your main results, if your rankings stall despite good content, or before a big content push, so the new content is built with link targets already in mind.

How many competitors should I include?

Three to five. Fewer makes it hard to spot domains that link to several rivals, which are your best targets. More than five produces a gap list so large that the sorting step, which is where the value sits, never gets done properly.

Can I do competitor backlink analysis for free?

Partly. Free checkers show a sample of a rival profile, which is enough to learn the method and find a handful of targets. The full gap workflow, with complete exports and overlap filtering, needs a paid tool, though a single month subscription is usually enough for a full pass.

Is it wrong to copy a competitor links?

Copying the idea is normal competitive research. Every business studies what works for rivals. What is against Google rules is buying the same paid links, joining the same link schemes, or copying a profile built on manipulation. Earn the same kinds of links with real outreach and your own content instead.

What if my competitors have ten times my links?

Then do not aim at their total. Filter the gap list to domains linking to several rivals, remove anything that exists because of their brand size, and chase the attainable slice: niche blogs, lists, suppliers, and local press. This is competitor backlink analysis used properly, as a filter rather than a fantasy. Closing a quality gap of twenty to forty domains changes results for smaller sites far more than the headline totals suggest.

Need backlinks?

Order guest posts on reviewed websites with honest metrics, or list your own site and get paid.

Join RankPublish
Keep reading